
I love to talk about my favorite show, Supernatural. There aren’t very many things I don’t like about it. But there are ten. So today I’m doing the Top Ten Things I Don’t Like about Supernatural. Read through my list, and see if you agree.
- John and Mary age 15 years in 4 years: We see the young versions of John and Mary in flashbacks. Dean goes back in time and meets with them twice, if I’m not mistaken. On the episode where Sam joins him in the past, Mary tells the boys that she is currently pregnant with Dean. So that means a little more than four years later, she’s dead, and she’s aged into the older version of Mary. I also think it’s weird when John travels to the future and gets to spend time with the older Mary. They are about the same age here. Yet, she died over twenty years ago. It just bugs me. Every time I see it, I’m like, this is so weird. I really wish they would have had a younger Mary and an older John.
- Chuck: Chuck was NOT supposed to be playing God. The people behind the show made the decision to change that after fans came up with this theory. I’m sorry, but this was dumb. Dean had a necklace that was supposed to burn in the presence of God, and even if you want to overlook that, the angels would have known who Chuck was. Castiel would have known. I liked Chuck until they changed his role. Now I can’t stand the episodes with him in it.
- Jack didn’t get rid of monsters: When the show ended, Jack brought everyone back that had disappeared during the final battle with Chuck. He could have left monsters out of the equation. Why did he choose to bring them back? That doesn’t make any sense to me. He could have sent them all the Purgatory and let the boys have a new start.
- Should have ended differently: I did not like the ending at all. After everything they went through together, Sam and Dean should have been together. If you figure their ages and that Sam didn’t die until he was an old man, Sam probably spent more of this life without Dean than with him. Or at least as long. I also hated it that they put Sam in a dreary home with Bobby’s old wallpaper. His life looked depressing even though he had a child. Where was the mother? Did she die like all his other loves? That’s worse than depressing. I really wish they would have ended it like this. Sam and Dean die while saving the world. They go to Purgatory and are attacked by monsters. John is suddenly there. He kills the monsters. Maybe Bobby should be there to help. John tells them to follow him. They need to hurry. He throws the weapons into the trunk. We have a trunk shot with all three Winchesters. John says something like, “Glad you’re finally here. We’re in the middle of a war, boys. Get ready. We’ve got work to do.” Then he slams the trunk shut, and viewers who are upset over the show ending at least know they are out there hunting still. Gives us hope for a movie or something.
- Exposition on first episode: The pilot episode. I cringe every time Sam complains that their dad has been hunting the thing that killed their mom for years and still hasn’t found it. He tells Dean things that Dean already knows, and it sounds so awkward. I heard someone from the show—I think it was Kripke—saying that it makes him cringe, too. If he could, he would do it differently.
- Demons Change Bodies: This is fine IF they would just act the same. Ruby becomes a totally different person when she changes from Katie Cassidy to Gen Padalecki. The demon should act and sound the same even if they are in a different body. We also see it happen with Meg. They should have just come up with different characters for these actors, because they were different characters. They just used names we were familiar with.
- Another Problem in the First Episode: When Sam is six months old, the lights flicker, and Mary just taps the lightbulb as though she knows nothing about hunting. I’m sure the producers had no idea that Mary was a hunter when the show first started. It happens. I just wish they had figured it out before they started shooting the show. We all know that flickering lights mean something supernatural is in the house.
- The Whole Angels/Demons/God Storyline: Surprisingly, there are a lot of Christians watching the show. Or at least there were until they decided to make God the bad guy. The worst thing about this is that some people know nothing about God or angels, and this is where they are getting their information. I heard one guy saying he was glad to find the show because he didn’t know anything about angels, and now he thinks he does. My advice to people watching the show that know nothing about God is, read the Bible. That’s where the truth can be found, not on shows like this.
- The Way They Eat: Sam could not survive on salad. The guy is pure muscle and needs a ton of protein. Dean couldn’t eat bacon cheeseburgers all the time (not to mention pie) and be in such great shape either. But I understand the way they eat adds funny moments to the show, so this doesn’t bother me as much as the other stuff. Just thought I’d throw it in.
- Fans Hating on the Women: I read an article by one of the producers saying that fans (female fans) hated the women characters. They were jealous or something and wanted the female characters gone as soon as they appeared. Bella was strongly disliked. Not by me. I thought they should have explored her terrible childhood sooner and how Crowley made a deal with her when she was a kid. Maybe it would have garnered enough sympathy to keep her around for a while. The only female character fans seemed to open their hearts to was Charlie, and that’s probably because she was gay. She wasn’t seen as a threat since she wasn’t interested in Sam or Dean. The show felt they had to keep those two single, so they killed Sam’s love interests and made Dean phobic about commitment. At least until he met Lisa. I don’t know how fans felt about her. The article was written before she came onboard, but they probably didn’t like her either.
Is there anything you think they should have done differently that I forgot to mention?
Don't forget to come back next Tuesday for another Top Ten list.